This Is My Definitive and Only Post About Putting Beer in Cans

beer-can-generic-blank-aluminum can

Everyone is talking about cans. For years – really, years – writers covering the beer industry have written stories on a near monthly basis about this “hot, new trend” in craft beer: breweries putting beer into cans.

This is one of my biggest pet peeves and it shows no signs of stopping. I recognize that part of it, as Norman Miller points out, is that the very average person (Elderly? WAKA WAKA.) may still be curious about cans and not understand why companies use cans.

OK.

From my biased, curmudgeon, Old Man Yells At Cloud point of view, it’s time to move beyond stories highlighting when a brewery puts liquid into a can. This is not innovative, this is not new and after several years of this happening within the space of craft beer, it is no longer a trend. It is a norm. According to tracking by the Brewers Association, about 2 percent of craft beer volume was going into cans in 2011. It was up to 10 percent in 2014, an increase of about 2 million barrels of beer.

I don’t have specific numbers beyond that, but I imagine your anecdotal experience aligns with mine and we can safely assume the percentage is much higher halfway through 2016. According to craftcans.com, 550 different breweries can 2,162 beers today.

Putting craft beer into a can is no longer a news story. It’s a press release.

So what the hell is there to actually write about cans? Beats the hell out of me, but guess I’ll try.

The Stats

This year-to-year increase is skewed because of the sheer volume of more cans appearing at retail outlets, but part of it certainly aligns with the fact that people are buying canned beer. Hell, even Founders All Day IPA 15-packs, as far as I know, the only such sized packaging in the industry, was up 183 percent during this time frame compared to 2015.

More sales means higher levels of comfort buying canned beer (whatever the hell that means to consumers, who are still frightened by aluminum, I guess) means greater proliferation of cans. It’s cyclical. Let’s not go overboard and write another dozen stories about how cool cans are.

The Business

In this context, I’m paying attention to the lower half of that chart focusing on beer bottles and growlers. The bottle part is easy: if more breweries are shifting packaging into cans or simply adding cans as a secondary means of packaging alongside bottles, sure, those requests are set to drop.

The growler thing is more interesting, because there are all sorts of reasons, from state laws (what and how you can fill) or the fact growler collections steadily grow (certain businesses will only fill their own). But I’d be really curious to better understand the impact of Oskar Blues’ Crowler, which seems more ubiquitous at places around me.

A partnership with Ball Corporation, U.S. breweries and bottle shops bought a little over 400 Crowler machines and 1.3 million Crowler cans in 2015. According to Jason Dan, Crowler specialist as Oskar Blues, both Texas and California bought the most Crowler machines during that time span, with bottle shops being an increasingly popular customer.

When I spoke this past winter to Jason and his colleague, Jeremy Rudolph, Oskar Blues’ Crowler CANministrator, they told me the cost for the machine was around $3,600 and orders for cans, which sell for 43 cents each, can’t go lower than 114 at a time. The average order for Crowler cans is a pallet of 2,400 at a cost of $1,032. That tells me that buyers feel confident in the machine and product because consumers are happy with cans.

The Availability

Thanks to the entrepreneurship of those seeing an opportunity within the beer industry, finding ways to can beer is also getting easier.

Mobile canning companies can be found in many major markets, from North Carolina to Indiana to California and everywhere in between.

“There’s no end of customers in sight,” Michael Horn, owner of Old Dominion Mobile Canning, told the Raleigh News & Observer. “Our pipeline is full.”

Horn’s company, based in Virginia, covers areas across the Mid-Atlantic and will fill more than 3 million cans in 2016.

A big part of that is cost of entry. For breweries who focus on draft sales initially – and bringing people into your taproom is not only popular, but pivotal – working with mobile canning units is a great step in the direction of packaging regularly. In Indiana, ICan charges as low as $1,600 for a 100-case run.

The Common Sense

I realize that from a consumer standpoint, it may be fun to have some of our favorite beers in a different, more portable package. As beer continues to fight for occasion-specific drinking sessions – cookouts and holidays make summer the most important beer sales time of the year – cans offer another avenue for businesses to access in an ongoing fight for share of dollars between spirits and wine.

But when it comes to being newsworthy, at least for the time being, we can give it a rest. I realize Lagunitas’ Tony Magee said four years ago he would never use cans and now his brewery is canning, but mistaking one of beer’s most outspoken personalities and his hyperbole as newsworthiness needs a second thought before putting pen to paper and fingers to keyboard. This is a man who works in grandiose statements.

At this point, we’ve moved well beyond the need to continually share stories about how cans are safe or cool or portable or whatever. We no longer have to write hundreds of words when we hear about a brewery – young or old – is going to use cans as a packaging of choice.

Those who can, do. Those who can’t, bottle. Let’s leave it at that.

Bryan Roth
“Don’t drink to get drunk. Drink to enjoy life.” — Jack Kerouac

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “This Is My Definitive and Only Post About Putting Beer in Cans

  1. $1600 for a 100 case run or $16.00 per case OR $0.70 cents per can – not including the cost of the can or the beer!

    Separately, all the places I’ve seen using the crowler in my area (Philadelphia Metropolitan area) have the crowler too far from the where the draught lines are. The whole point of canning is removing oxygen from the package (and light). Most places aren’t filling the crawler to max so when it’s moved they don’t spill. Oskar Blues says they’ve added a CO2 purging step to the process that you’re supposed to do before filling, however if you purge and have to then move to fill (and you don’t fill with beer to very brim) you’re going to end up with oxygen in package.

    • That’s the smallest amount of cans, though, so I’m sure the price gets better if the brewery goes bigger. There’s also the difference between pre-printed cans and shrink wrapped ones, which I’ve heard to be 3 or 4 times more expensive.

      Bonus on the Crowler: Oskar Blues is going to release a resealable version this year!

  2. Most of the craft beers that I drink I prefer in bottles. However, there are several places that I go where bottles are not allowed. At the beach, and now some campgrounds are going glass-free because of assholes leaving broken bottles. The park rangers tell me that cans are easier to clean up, and have greater value for trade in (especially in Oregon to the south of me) which helps the parks in a small way.

    • Ha! Bombers don’t get stories written about them when breweries put beer in large bottles.

      This isn’t a post about the vessel in which beer is placed, but rather trying to find context as to why it’s seen as such a big deal.

  3. Pingback: Would You Like To Take That In The Can? | Bearcat On Beer

  4. Pingback: You Can Listen to Me Talk About Beer, Too | This Is Why I'm Drunk

  5. Pingback: Let’s Talk Doom, Gloom and Craft Beer Bubbles | This Is Why I'm Drunk

  6. Pingback: We’re Growing More Hops Than Ever, But There’s More to the Story | This Is Why I'm Drunk

  7. Pingback: The Full Story Behind Hops, Beer Production and Our Love of IPAs | This Is Why I'm Drunk

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s